Bedtime guide
Cognitive shuffling for sleep: how it works and how to build a word list
Cognitive shuffling is a falling-asleep technique where you picture a series of random, unrelated, neutral things for a few seconds each, such as a bicycle, then a banana, then a bucket. Developed by cognitive scientist Luc Beaudoin, it aims to occupy the mind with the kind of loose, disconnected imagery that naturally happens as you drift off, leaving less room for worry or problem-solving. Evidence is early: related research shows imagery distraction can shorten time to fall asleep, but direct tests of the shuffle are small.
Why random pictures instead of counting sheep
Lying awake usually involves a particular kind of thinking: making sense of things. Replaying a conversation, planning tomorrow, checking whether you are asleep yet. Each thought connects to the next, and connected thinking keeps the mind engaged.
Luc Beaudoin, a cognitive scientist at Simon Fraser University, built cognitive shuffling around the opposite. As people fall asleep, their thoughts naturally become fragmented and dreamlike. His idea is that deliberately producing that kind of disconnected imagery may both crowd out sense-making and resemble the mental state of sleep onset. He calls the method serial diverse imagining.
Counting sheep is repetitive but not very absorbing, which leaves room for worry to slip back in. Shuffling asks for just enough effort, picturing a new object every few seconds, to keep your attention occupied without giving it anything to solve.
What the evidence shows
The honest summary is: plausible, low-risk, and lightly tested.
- Imagery distraction helps some people with insomnia. In a study of people with insomnia, those instructed to use imagery to distract themselves at bedtime fell asleep faster and reported less unwanted pre-sleep thinking than those given general distraction instructions or none (Harvey and Payne, 2002). This supports the general approach, not the shuffle specifically.
- The shuffle itself has preliminary tests. Beaudoin’s group presented early results comparing the cognitive shuffle with a constructive-worry exercise in a 2015 conference paper (Digdon and Beaudoin, 2015). Beaudoin has said more studies are needed.
- It is not an insomnia treatment. For chronic insomnia, cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) is the recommended first-line approach (American Academy of Sleep Medicine guideline, 2021). Shuffling is a bedtime tool you might use alongside it, not a substitute.
How to do it
- Pick a seed word with no emotional charge, such as BLANKET.
- Take its first letter, B, and think of words starting with B: bicycle, bread, button, balloon.
- Picture each one for about five to fifteen seconds. Let the image be rough. Then move on.
- When B runs dry, move to the next letter of the seed word, L: lamp, lemon, ladder, leaf.
- If a worry returns, do not argue with it. Just go to the next word.
- Stop whenever you like. Many people drift off before the seed word is finished. Staying awake through the whole list is not a failure.
Build a word list that actually works
The method stands or falls on the words. Each item should pass four tests:
| Test | Keep | Swap out | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Easy to picture | spoon, kite, pinecone | justice, plan | Abstract words invite thinking, not picturing |
| Emotionally neutral | teapot, sock | hospital, ex-partner’s car | Charged words pull you back into sense-making |
| Unrelated to the last item | bucket after banana | bucket after shovel | Linked items form a story; the goal is disconnection |
| Not about tomorrow | cactus, feather | laptop, inbox | Work objects start the planning loop again |
Worked example (invented). Someone’s first attempt with the letter P was: phone, paperwork, presentation, pillow. Three of four fail the tests: the phone and paperwork are tomorrow’s tasks, and “presentation” is the very thing they were worrying about. A revised P list: pear, paintbrush, penguin, pebble, parasol, pretzel. Each is concrete, neutral and unrelated to the one before.
If you shuffle often, write three or four seed words that work for you on a note by the bed, so you do not need to choose one at night.
Make a shuffle you can listen to
Generating words yourself is part of the method, but some people find it too effortful when very tired, or they get stuck judging their own choices. An audio version can do the choosing for you: a calm voice says one neutral object, waits several seconds, and says the next. You can create a cognitive shuffle recording in Manai, read the word list before producing audio, and swap out any word that has a personal association. If you notice yourself checking whether it is “working,” our guide to trying too hard to fall asleep explains how to give a bedtime recording a modest job.
Original illustrative request, not a tested example:
Make a 20-minute cognitive shuffle for bedtime. Use seed words BLANKET and HARBOR. Say one concrete, everyday object at a time, starting with each letter in turn. Every object should be neutral and unrelated to the one before it. No work items, no screens, no people, no medical words. Wait about ten seconds between words. Very soft, slow voice, no music, and no ending that wakes me up; just let the words get further apart and stop.
Read the generated list once before you listen. Remove anything that has a personal meaning for you.
Frequently asked questions
What is cognitive shuffling?
It is a technique for falling asleep in which you picture a series of random, unrelated, neutral objects, usually by working through words that start with each letter of a seed word. It was developed by cognitive scientist Luc Beaudoin, who calls it serial diverse imagining.
Does cognitive shuffling work?
It may help some people. Research on imagery distraction found people with insomnia fell asleep faster when they used imagery to distract themselves, and early tests of the shuffle were presented in 2015. Large independent trials of the shuffle itself are still lacking.
How long should I picture each word?
About five to fifteen seconds is the range usually described. Long enough to form a rough picture, short enough that you do not start building a story around it.
What if my mind keeps going back to worries?
That is normal. Do not try to push the worry away or analyze it. Simply say the next word and picture it. If worry dominates night after night, try moving planning to earlier in the evening, and consider CBT-I if sleep problems persist.
Is cognitive shuffling better than meditation for sleep?
They do different jobs. Shuffling deliberately keeps the mind lightly busy with disconnected images, while many sleep meditations guide attention to the breath or body. Some people find one easier than the other; trying each for a week is a reasonable way to choose.
Create your personal practice with Manai →
Manai offers educational wellness practices. It is not medical care, diagnosis, or treatment. If a practice feels uncomfortable, stop. Seek qualified support for health concerns or urgent distress.